|
CES 2008 comments
"Playing the Tape
Project's open reel reissue of Reference Recordings Tutti, the TAD
(Reference One) presented one of the most completely persuasive facsimiles
of a symphony I've heard from a system. Voices and smaller groups were
equally convincing, with unsurpassed tonal truth and beauty. For me this
was the sonic Everest of the show, indeed, of many a show."
Paul Seydor - PS's
Best of Show - The Absolute Sound, April/May 2008
"The TAD room was
noteworthy not just for its excellent speakers, but also for the best
sounding source of the show: The Tape Project's direct-from-master
analog tape."
Alan Taffel - AT's
Best of Show - The Absolute Sound, April/May 2008
"...excellent
source material tipped the scales for me. I loved the massed strings and
dynamic headroom via The Tape Project’s master tape (duplicate -ed.)
on the TAD Reference One..."
Jim Hannon's Best of
Show - AVGuide.com,
The Absolute Sound, April/May 2008
"Also on the 34th
floor was Andrew Jones’ beautiful, three-way, floorstanding TAD
Reference One loudspeaker ($60k)–with its famous concentric beryllium
midrange/tweeter and two ported 10-inch woven-Aramid-sandwich
woofers–fed by Ayre electronics and one of The Tape Project 15ips,
two-track tape players. The sound on the tapes was, needless to say,
astonishing."
Jonathan Valin - AVGuide.com,
The Absolute Sound, April/May 2008
"A demo using the
big, full-range TADs demonstrated that open-reel analog tape still
smokes even high-resolution (24-bit/192kHz) digital."
Michael Fremer -
Stereophile, April 2008
Impressions from
Tape Project Subscribers
TP-009
Oh Boy, that sounded
nice! You just can't keep you feet from tapping all the way through
that album. And even though the famous Van Gelder "hole in the
middle" is in evidence on the vocal cuts Mose's voice fill
that void very nicely. Real intimate stuff for the most part and his
voice sounds is spot on in the realism department. It kinda reminds me
of one of those pictures that you have to look at just the right way
to see the baby or the dinosaur but once you see it, you can't not
see it. It's that same way with Mose Allison. Once you hear his vocal
style, you hear his influence everywhere!
And when this trio swings, it cooks! Farmer and Free just drives this
stuff. It must've been such a pleasure to watch Allison play since
"fluid" comes to mind every time I hear him. I know he was a
big Bud Powell fan and you can hear that on this album but Mose really
took that thing to another level and made it his own.
I know I should be saying more about the fidelity of this tape but
sometimes the music just doesn't allow that. At least not on the first
listen.
BTW Anyone know where this one was recorded. It sure doesn't
sound like an apartment in Jersey.
Charter member Steve
Koto, aka ironbut
TP-008
TP008 is an unqualified
home run!!!
i'm guessing no one is surprised about that. a first class 15ips master
dub of arguably the most popular live Jazz trio album of all time should
be outstanding; and it is...
what struck me first was the level of realism from a 47 year old
recording. from the very start i was there seated in a stage center
table; with Evans piano just to my right up on the stage and LaFaro's
bass to my left.....and Motian a bit back and left of center. every tiny
nuance was there and the subtlety of everything was spooky. like Ironbut;
i had the feeling that this was the complete picture of how it was. i
have many Bill Evans recordings. i've never heard the nuance and
subtlety of his playing like this. the fingering of the keys was
magical. really; the same with LaFaro. it was so intimate feeling i was
out of my listening comfort zone and i was trying to get my bearings. it
seemed to cross over into really real territory. made the hair stand up
and all that. looked over my shoulder a few times.
there was nothing between me and them. no mics or recording chain was
evident.
the brush work from Motian had this delicate 3-dimentionality to it and
such micro-dynamic life. the whole recording has such an alive level of
dynamic realism.....unveiled and natural.
everything had such a natural place in space front to back, side to
side, and top to bottom. nothing cookie cutter, just real life in real
space. i'm assuming that as close to the original event as this is
everything is in perfect phase. just music.
and oh, what music. perfect sound meets inspired playing; with
historically great synergy and talent. three guys at their individual
musical peaks.
i had intended to write mostly about how this compared to the AP 45rpm
LP reissue.....which was my reference for 'Waltz for Debbie'. i have
been eagerly anticipating doing the comparison to see how a 45rpm LP
played on a top level tt compared to 'The Tape Project' 15ips 1/4"
version played on a top level RTR deck. but after doing the comparison,
it's easy to hear how the tape is better in every way and the 45rpm Lp
(as good as it is) is not really close to this level of realism.
Charter Member Mike
Lavigne, aka mikel
TP-007
I got home from work
pretty worn out from the day. My mood quickly changed when I spied the
UPS box waiting patiently for me beside the door. I have to confess that
I didn't own this Reference Recording until now, but it was a favorite
demo CD at a local audio salon (Music Lovers). For those not familiar
with Exotic Dances from the Opera, it includes seven pieces from seven
different composers. Now I'm not the type that goes for the audiophile
extravaganzas and perhaps my prolonged absence from the local audio
shops has helped but each one of these selections just knocked my socks
off. Starting with the Rimsky-Korsakov, then one after the other stepped
up to the plate to hit the ball deeper into the stands until ending with
the Saint-Saens. I recall reading Doc's posting from CES (on the
Bottlehead forum since this one didn't exist yet) where he premiered the
tapes and he said that they were given a standing ovation. Well, I felt
like doing the same thing by them time this tape ended.
So what's so great about this tape,.. drum hits like I've never heard
outside of a concert hall. So realistic and full. You just have to hear
it to know. The woodwind solos are so concrete that you could easily
describe the players technique. No congestion on the gigantic swells (oh
god, did I say that the dynamic swing is amazing) at all. This thing
puts you there so solidly that when the music ended, my first thought
was "Why isn't anyone clapping?". But it isn't all swagger
either. There's a section where a cello comes to the fore and there's
all that resin, as we'd expect, but there's such a woody tone from the
box and a space that it occupies like I usually only hear from a
baritone singer on a great recording. Just fantastic!
As I've said in a previous post, I've found the selections to be more
than I could have asked for, but all for different reasons. TP 005 and
006 are classic performances that original LP's would set you back as
much or more than the pristine tapes that are offered. But 007 (lord,
I've gone this far without any Ian Fleming references and I'm not going
to start now,..MoneyPenny) really gets the "showoff" in me
excited. If ever there was a release that shows the impressive side of
what our tapes and systems can do, this is it!
When you get this tape,.. your neighbors are going to know it!
Charter Subscriber
Steve Koto, aka ironbut
TP-006
Got it about 2PM. I've
already played about half of the Bruch Scottish Fantasy. Wonderful.
Oistrakh can really play the fiddle. Another winner for TP. :-) I am
comparing it to my vinyl copy, an original London (not Decca) (matrix
1E) pressing. The tape has an openness and depth and breadth of image
that is lacking in the vinyl - though the latter is really very good...The
Hindemith is even better than the Bruch. Very nice.
Charter Subscriber Larry
Toy, aka Astrotoy
The thing I really love
about this release is how natural sounding it is. I get so used to the
overloaded, audiophile hyped sound that sometimes when I go to
performances of the SF Symphony, I start out a little underwhelmed. But
as the music and performance unfolds, and I resign myself to following
the conductors hands and the composers intentions, the score reveals
itself like a well lit road with an unknown destination. TP-006 allows
this to happen. I've waited so long and searched so hard for a recording
that I could say this about with no reservation. From the resiny edge of
Oistrakl's bow, to the tremendous crashes of multiple percussive
instruments, it falls on my ears as it should. No distractions,.. just
you and the music.
Nice job guys!
Charter Subscriber
Steve Koto, aka ironbut
Comparing TP-005 to
Vinyl
I was in Paul and
Mike's studio on Wed and Mike handed me TP-005. The Suite Española
has been one of my favorite demo records. I have an early London
(grooved label, 1G lacquer) and a Speaker's Corner reissue (which to
me is inferior to the early London). The dynamic range, with many
quick crescendos, lots of percussion - clicking castanets and
attractive tunes, make this record a lot of fun. Before TP-005, I
thought that the London was a great disc. But, after comparing the
first cut - TP-005 is the clear winner. Two points - the depth and
subtlety of the lower levels of the orchestra is amazing - you can
hear into the orchestra so much more deeply - the bouncing bows of
violins within the first minute of the piece is a good example.
Second, the ease of the dynamic transitions, as in the other tapes -
no strain. Another winner. I've got to go back and listen again.
Having heard a couple of excerpts from the "Exotic Dances"
album in demos - can't wait for the next one.
Charter Subscriber
Larry Toy, aka Astrotoy
TP-003 - Oh my!
"Well, I finally
got my homebrew preamp to a point where it's about listenable and hooked
it up to my new Flux Magnetics head in my spare RS-1500 headblock.
TP-003 (Arnold Overtures) has been on hand for a while, but I didn't
want to listen until I had the IEC eq working, and that meant getting
the preamp up and running. Wow.... I finally understand what
everybody's talking about. Everything about the recording is just
so right. There's just this orchestra out there in space, well not
exactly in space, it's an orchestra in a complete acoustic environment
and after a few moments I found myself listening with this big grin on
my face, even giggling at parts of the goofy Christmas Overture.
Beautiful, full clearly articulated lows, sweet highs and everything
else in between just in the right place. I've never heard anything
else like it in my house. To docb, romo and Paul you've hit it out
the park! Thanks."
Subscriber Richard
Lane, aka Scully 280
Get them while they
last!
"
Yesterday I finally was able to play my first Tape Project tape:
TP-001 Jacqui Naylor, The Number White.
I'm using a Technics RS-1500 deck (without any of Doc mods -yet-) with
its stock heads wired directly to a Seduction modified for tape
playback, an extended
Foreplay III and a pair of 45 amps (basically BHs excites) to a
pair of edgarhorns.
I suscribed to the TP about a year ago, brought my tapes home after
Christmas and finished my Seduction a few weeks ago but still needed
some break-in time.
All I can say is Wow! This is the way it is supposed to be. The music
and the singer's voice are as natural as they can be. You could listen
to this stuff for hours and not get tired... Just fantastic.
My only problem is that I couldn't crank up the volume up because my
kids were sleeping. I guess I need to start
working on my home's S.E.X.
amp with Ni iron and BH cable upgrade on two sets of HD-600s that
I have ready for whenever I finish my home theater.
Believe me, if you're thinking about jumping into the TP now is the
time, when Series One titles are still available: you won't regret it."
Charter Subscriber
Xavier Cortes
"Until last night I
had only used my tape Seduction in NAB mode on 4 track tapes at 7.5 IPS
on my RS-1506. The results haven't been ideal as the level seemed lower
than other sources.
Last night I cleaned the tape path and loaded up reel one of the Arnold
Overtures (TP-003). Wow! Signal level was perfect. I poured two
fingers of Lagavulin single malt and enjoyed 30+ minutes of incredible
sound.
Thanks to Doc and the Tape Project gang."
Subscriber AZ Gary
"We opened a bottle
of wine and threaded up TP-002 tonight. Another home run for the Tape
Project. The sound of the guitar and Dave Alvin's voice reached out to
us, not in a hyped up "audiophile" way, but in an emotional
way, just as live music does. Can't wait for TP-003!"
Charter Subscriber
Dan Robertson
"Mmm! Huh,.. did
someone say something! Oh Yeah,.. I am listening to it right now. Talk
about engaging! Nice job Romo. I think this is the mixing/mastering
equivalent to the fear that TV stars had about close-ups when they
caught wind of what HD TV was capable of. That's if you can stop tapping
your foot long enough to listen into the mix. This sounds so good that
it's hard not to be transported to the Camellia room. I was thinking
that it might sound better than the demo tape but maybe it's more of a
matter of getting the intent of the album and the mood of the players.
The comments at the end of the cuts are wonderful. I don't know if
they're on the CD but I'm a real sucker for this kind of thing.
The package came in perfect condition. The engraving looks mighty nice
and I love the foil edge art. The pictures don't do justice to the
package as a whole.
Michael's right though. I wouldn't put a $30 rib eye on the grill and
figure that you'll listen to just one cut. You can forget about that!
You won't want it to ever end!
Thanks guys,.. we're doin' the antler dance tonight!"
Charter Subscriber
ironbut, about TP-001, Jacqui Naylor, The Number White
"Paul - package received,
and I must say, very,very impressive. I am finishing up my MTR-10
alignment this weekend (just received my new heads from JRF), and hope
to have TP-001 spinning for the holiday. My thanks to you and Doc and
Michael for this wonderful initiative. Looking forward to all my
selections in the coming weeks."
"I have received the
TP-001 tape and I am extremely pleased with the results of the deck and
the tape itself. Goose pimple good."
Subscriber Jack
Fuller
"Mine arrived today..and
I am pretty stoked. The packaging and presentation are
outstanding.....the pictures don't do it justice. My hat is off to Doc
B, Romo and Paul."
Charter Subscriber
mikel
"I received TP 001
Wednesday evening. You have done an excellent job with The Tape
Project. It is an absolute first class job in every detail.
It was a true sense of satisfaction to hear the music and made the
wait and effort into putting my system together well worth it. I
wish you much success."
Subscriber Pete
DeRosa
Impressions of the
Tape Project from
Head-fi NorCal Regional Meet, August 25, 2007
"one word--WOW.
This had to be the most musical and emotionally moving listening
experience I've encountered. It's extremely rare I can listen to
unfamiliar music and feel so moved and hang on every note, wishing it
not end. The (Tape Project) tape had an utter breathtaking realism that
everything else just melted away. It doesn't do it justice to use
audiophile terms, which usually best describe an artificial attempt at
replicating sound. Dare I say it, the closest to the real deal--like
being in the studio on the musicians side of the glass. While listening
I had goosebumps, walking away I had goosebumps, a bit later talking
about it I got goosebumps or even thinking about it right now I am
relishing the moment and sighing long and hard because I don't know when
something so emotionally intense can happen again."
Head-fi member 909
"It has already
been said, but ironbut's rig is truly extraordinary. The same Tape
Project (demo) tape was at HE2007 and on a hugemongous speaker setup it
had the same impact on me. Natural, fleshy sound that cannot be beaten
by digital sources, and I don't think that I have heard a vinyl setup
that can match that same kind of sound."
Head-fi member
Voltron
"Ironbut's Technics
reel to reel > Bottlehead tape pre > Zana Duex > Ed9s this was
the best sound I have EVER heard. The mastering on that reel was crazy
good this rig removed the last pane of glass that separates you from the
music. Not only was it detailed but had a lifelike quality that sends a
shiver down your spine."
Head-fi member
jp11801
"tape
project...just **** amazing way to hear music. I listened to the
classical recording on the tape and everything was so completely 3
dimensional in terms of sound...texture, soundstage, incredible weight
to the music."
Head-fi member foo_me
TAS
comments on the The Tape Project in the MAGICO
room at CES 2007
"Folks,
I've heard some mighty fine stereo systems over the years...But fed by
the Technics tape deck and those Japanese oddball electronics
from BA Labo, the Magico Model 6s reached a level of realism from full
orchestra to solo voice that I've simply never heard matched."
-
Jonathan Valin, Best of Show CES 2007,The
Absolute Sound, April/May 2007
"The
best systems were Ray Kimber's...the Spectral system... and the MAGICO
Model 6, fed from a 15ips analog tape machine."
-
Robert Harley, Best of Show CES 2007, The
Absolute Sound, April/May 2007
"perhaps
the most convincing recreation of a symphony orchestra I have ever
heard" - Wayne
Garcia, on hearing an excerpt from Arnold Overtures on the MAGICO/Tape
Project combination, Best of Show CES 2007, The
Absolute Sound, April/May 2007
Positive
Feedback on Tape Project tapes in the E.A.R. U.S.A room at CES 2007
"the
sound was no less than drop dead stunning. Dynamic, ultra-resolved, it
makes digital high-res formats look pale, flat and sad in
comparison." -
Danny Kaey,
2007 CES, Positive Feedback Online Issue 29 |